Key takeaways
- Frontier starts cheapest at $32,150 and is the only one of the four that skips a turbo engine entirely.
- Colorado tows the most, up to 7,700 lbs. Ford rates Ranger's payload best in class at up to 1,809 lbs.
- Tacoma is the only truck here with a hybrid option, the i-FORCE MAX, up to 326 hp and 465 lb-ft.
- Ranger's Raptor trim is the most powerful of the four at 405 hp.
- All four carry the same basic warranty: 3 years/36,000 miles bumper-to-bumper, 5 years/60,000 miles powertrain.
If you're cross-shopping midsize trucks in Halifax County, you've probably narrowed it to these four: Frontier, Tacoma, Ranger, and Colorado. They're closer in price than you'd think, and further apart in how they're built than the spec sheets first suggest.
We put the real numbers side by side below, no rounding up, no cherry-picked trim to make one truck look better. Where a spec depends heavily on cab or drivetrain, we say so instead of picking whichever number looks best.
We wrote a full breakdown of why the Frontier itself is having a strong year in our Frontier awards and sales post. This post is about how it stacks up against the other three trucks parked at every dealer on this stretch of I-95.
The spec comparison
| Frontier | Tacoma | Ranger | Colorado | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting MSRP | $32,150 | $32,545 | $33,350 | $32,400 |
| Base engine | 3.8L V6, 310 hp / 281 lb-ft | 2.4L turbo I-4, 228 hp / 243 lb-ft | 2.3L turbo I-4, 270 hp / 310 lb-ft | 2.7L turbo I-4, 310 hp / 430 lb-ft |
| Top engine | Same V6, only engine offered | i-FORCE MAX hybrid, up to 326 hp / 465 lb-ft | 3.0L twin-turbo V6 (Raptor), 405 hp / 430 lb-ft | Same turbo I-4, only engine offered |
| Max towing | 7,150 lbs | 6,500 lbs | 7,500 lbs (5,510 lbs on Raptor) | 7,700 lbs |
| Max payload | 1,620 lbs | About 1,705 to 1,710 lbs | 1,805 to 1,809 lbs | Varies widely by trim |
| EPA combined MPG (best trim, estimated) | 21 | 23 | 23 | About 18 |
| Bed length | 59.5 in (73.3 in on Long Bed) | 6 ft on SR/XtraCab; 5 ft on Double Cab | 5 ft (only configuration) | 5 ft / 61.7 in (only configuration) |
| Off-road trims | PRO-4X, PRO-4X R by Roush, Dark Armor package | TRD PreRunner, TRD Off-Road, Trailhunter, TRD Pro | Raptor | Trail Boss, Z71, ZR2 |
| Warranty | 3 yr/36,000 mi basic, 5 yr/60,000 mi powertrain | Same | Same | Same |
Towing and payload figures come from each manufacturer's own published specs and vary by cab, drivetrain, and options. Treat them as ceilings, not a guarantee for any single truck on our lot. MPG figures are EPA estimates.
Where the Frontier wins
No turbo, anywhere in the lineup. Every trim runs the same 3.8L V6, so there's no engine tier to decide between. It's also the cheapest of the four to start, at $32,150, and it picked up real recognition this year: Newsweek's No. 1 Best New Truck for 2026, plus a spot on Consumer Reports' 2026 Recommended list. We cover that in more depth in our Frontier awards post.
Where Tacoma wins
Tacoma is the only truck in this group with a hybrid option. The i-FORCE MAX pairs a turbo four with an electric motor for up to 326 hp and 465 lb-ft, more torque than anything here besides the Ranger Raptor. A manual transmission is still available on some non-hybrid trims too, if that matters to you. And Toyota runs a wide trim ladder, from a base SR turbo four up through the hybrid Trailhunter and TRD Pro, so there's more room to move within one model.
Where Ranger wins
Ford's payload numbers lead this group, up to 1,805 to 1,809 lbs depending on configuration. The Raptor trim is also the most powerful truck here by a wide margin, 405 hp and 430 lb-ft from a twin-turbo V6. Ranger also runs a 10-speed automatic across the whole lineup, one more gear than Frontier's 9-speed.
Where Colorado wins
Colorado has the highest max towing of the four, up to 7,700 lbs, which Chevrolet calls class-leading. The ZR2 trim adds real off-road hardware too: locking front and rear differentials and up to 10.7 inches of ground clearance.
Which truck fits you
Running a work truck around Roanoke Rapids and Weldon, and you just need something reliable that doesn't ask you to think about turbo maintenance? Frontier's simplicity and price make it the easy call.
Hauling a loaded trailer to Lake Gaston or pulling equipment out to hunting land in Northampton County, with towing as the number you care about most? Colorado's 7,700-lb rating gives you the most room, with Ranger close behind at 7,500.
Care more about gas mileage on the Rocky Mount commute than raw power? Tacoma and Ranger post the best combined EPA numbers here at 23 mpg on their most efficient trims, with the Frontier 4x2 at 21.
Want the most truck for weekend trail runs and don't mind paying for it? Ranger Raptor is the outlier of this group on power.
Just want a truck that does the job without a spec-sheet arms race? That's the Frontier's whole pitch, and it's a big part of why its sales numbers have moved the way they have this year.
Frequently asked questions
Which midsize truck tows the most?
The Colorado, with a max rating up to 7,700 lbs, which Chevrolet markets as class-leading. Ranger is close behind at 7,500 lbs on non-Raptor trims.
Which midsize truck has the most payload?
Ford rates the Ranger best in class at up to 1,805 to 1,809 lbs. Payload swings a lot by cab, drivetrain, and trim on every truck here, so compare the exact configuration you're buying.
Is the Frontier's V6 turbocharged?
No. It's the only naturally aspirated engine in this group. Tacoma, Ranger, and Colorado all use a turbocharged engine as their base powertrain.
Which of these trucks is cheapest?
The Frontier, starting at $32,150. Tacoma and Colorado are close behind in the $32,400 to $32,550 range, and Ranger starts highest of the four at $33,350.
Does any of these trucks come as a hybrid?
Yes, the Tacoma. Toyota's i-FORCE MAX hybrid is available on the Trailhunter and TRD Pro trims, producing up to 326 hp and 465 lb-ft of torque.
Which one is the most powerful?
The Ford Ranger Raptor, at 405 hp and 430 lb-ft from a twin-turbo 3.0L V6. Among base engines, Colorado's turbo four makes the most torque at 430 lb-ft.
Come see it at Nissan of Roanoke Rapids
Every one of these trucks has a real strength. Ours is parked at 407 Premier Blvd in Roanoke Rapids, right off I-95. Come drive the Frontier back to back with whatever else is on your list. We're not worried about the comparison. We're open Monday through Friday 9 AM to 7 PM and Saturday 9 AM to 6 PM, closed Sunday. Call 252-677-5679 or stop by to check current inventory.